Cover
Vol. 17 No. 2 (2017)

Published: September 30, 2017

Pages: 38-42

Original Article

Experimental Investigation of the Dynamics of Laboratory Simple Surge Tank

Abstract

The surge tank is one of important control devices in reducing water Hummer effect on distributed network piping system and hydropower stations. An experimental study was conducted into a simple surge tank of 0.044 m in a diameter with upstream constant head reservoir of a height, 0.881 m and a water transporting pipe of a size 0.0202 m. Results indicate that rapid closure of a downstream valve causes under-damped stable oscillation in a surge tank. Experimental response agreed well with theoretical results when friction factor is considered to be variable, but with 85 % increases in settle time and more oscillations when constant friction factor is recognized at initial value before valve closure. Doubling surge tank area does not improve the dynamics properties; otherwise, Thoma area must be avoided for small sizes. Comsol multiphysics software 3.5 is used to deal with the dynamics of the surge tank numerically.

References

  1. M.C. Friedman, "Verification and control of low pressure transients in distributed system", Proc. 18 th Annual ASDWA Conf. Boston, 2003.
  2. J. F. Douglas, M. Gasiorek and J. A. Swaffield, “Fluid Mechanics”, 3 rd ed., Longman, 1998
  3. S. H. Kim, (2010). “Design of surge tank for water supply systems using the impulse response method with the GA algorithm”, Journal of Mechanical Science and Technology Vol. 24, No. 2, pp. 629-636.
  4. Mawash, P. R. and Gross, R. H. (2001). “ Understanding the nonlinear dynamics of liquid flow with surge tanks”, International Journal of Mechanical Engineering Education, Vol. 29, No. 1, pp. 53-66.
  5. D. Borkowski, (2016). "Water level control of a small hydropower plant with a surge tank ", Journal of Hydraulic Research 55(2):1-8.
  6. M. H. Chaudhry, "Applied Hydraulic Transient”, Litton Educational Publishing", 1979.
  7. R. Darby, “Chemical Engineering Fluid Mechanics”, 2 nd ed., Marcel Dekker, 2001
  8. COMSOL Inc. "Chemical Engineering Module, Model Library", Version 3.5a, pp. 613, 2008
  9. Instruction manual. "Pipe surge and water hammer apparatus", Armfield, C7-00, Issue 11.1988
  10. C. Jaeger, " A review of surge tank stability criteria", Journal of Basic Engineering, ASME, Dec., pp. 765-775, 1960.